Oh, sure, let's play a game.

Name a single theatrical production that occurred before you were born that you'd like to time-travel back to see.

(It doesn't have to be the absolute only, but you can name only one.)

For me today: Hart and Kaufman's Once in a Lifetime (1931)

Jean Dixon as May Daniels, Hugh O'Connell as George Lewis, and Grant Mills as Jerry Hyland in Once in a Lifetime

Replies

  1. i've always wanted to see the very first performance of richard iii put on by shakespeare for king charles in 1633. small playhouse, first big play, no scenery—they must have been petrified and it was extremely well received, thus a notable (for the record) performance and it's a formidable story.

    2
  2. I immediately thought of the legendary 1961 production of The Blacks at St. Mark’s: Roscoe Lee Browne, Lou Gossett, Cecily Tyson, Godfrey Cambridge, Arthur French, Maya Angelou. I would crawl through space and time to be there.

    A program from the 1961 production of Genet’s The Blacks.
    0
  3. Well, it opened when I was four, but I'd love to see Ethel Merman in the original Broadway production of "Gypsy."

    Or Julie Andrews in "My Fair Lady" (I was one).

    0
  4. Hamlet at the National Theatre in 1963. O’toole in the title role, Olivier directing… and Derek Jacobi fighting for his actual life in V.ii every single night because (after almost four uncut hours) Hamlet was raving drunk.

    Read about Peter O'Toole's performance of Hamlet at the National Theatre in 1963, as a companion piece to the production of Sam Mendes' The Motive and the Cue.

    Archive Unboxed: Peter O'Toole in Hamlet, 1963 | National Theatre

    Read about Peter O'Toole's performance of Hamlet at the National Theatre in 1963, as a companion piece to the production of Sam Mendes' The Motive and the Cue.

    0
  5. Julie Andrews in The Boyfriend on Broadway, 1954. Growing up, the soundtrack LP played in regular rotation with The Pajama Game and Camelot among others.

    Dad mighta been gay.

    0
  6. Sigh.

    I did see a college production, though, with Harry Groener as Jerry -- he also did the choreography for a tap-dancing Jeffrey Combs...

    1
  7. Anyone Can Whistle, the whole mess.

    My real time machine show, though, occurred after I was born: second workshop of A Chorus Line, when it was four hours long.

    0
  8. The Broadway run of Sherlock Holmes, 1899, with Gillette in the lead role. Definitely before my time!

    1
  9. The sort of question whose answer will change daily. Tonight, two jumped to mind, but I’ll choose one, as per instructions: Angela Lansbury in Mame.

    0
  10. The original RSC production of Dangerous Liaisons, with Lindsay Duncan, Alan Rickman and Juliet Stevenson.

    1