geofffhughes.bsky.social profile picture

Geoffrey Hughes

@geofffhughes.bsky.social

1850 Followers

594 Following

Teacher, Ethnographer, Arabist; Lecturer in Anthropology and author of Affection and Mercy: Kinship, Islam and the Politics of Marriage in Jordan ♥️🇯🇴♥️🇵🇸 (he/هو)

https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=lLU0JwkAAAAJ&hl=en&oi=ao

  1. The question is not "why is the Atlantic platforming this guy?" The whole point of the Atlantic is to cut this sort of stuff with enough adulterants that seem vaguely "normal" that you don't realize what you're doing to yourself when you're imbibing their editorial line:

    The author is a Peter Thiel acolyte and founder of Pirate Wires, a publication occupying the niche that includes odes to Kyle Rittenhouse; scorn for "legacy media," academia, and wokeness; exposes of anti-white discrimination; and robust defenses of masculinity.

    Finally, a voice for the voiceless!

    1
  2. Even if we're being purely Machiavellian, a lot of this corner-cutting is so counterproductive. I got so much flak not making positions 1 year for a grant, but in practice that would mean the postdoc comes in and immediately begins applying for new jobs instead of doing the one they were hired to do

    1
  3. I think it's the opposite.

    I see Dawn of Everything as making the central point that human civilization was capable of anything, and it independently experimented with many different forms of organization before choosing hierarchy and capitalism.

    It implies agency where the ET theory does not.

    That said, I can't help but think of Dawn of Everything as a far more sophisticated and voluminously documented version of the 60s/70s-era books that explained the startling technological achievements of ancient civilizations using extraterrestrial deus ex machina interventions.

    2