Top comedian of all-time is a hard and subjective question but I think we can agree any one of these choices would be worthy of the honor
Replies
-
de gustibus but I vote for the Chrysler Building
-
How dare you include such a no talent hack and cheap mimic of actual comedy, Carlin didn’t even make real jokes
-
It's Fallon of course!
re-reads post
Oh sorry, I thought you were asking who should be thrown into an active volcano.
-
When you know it's a joke but also it still makes you mad
-
-
I recognize this is bait, but...
Shout out to Dave Chappelle, who would totally be on this list if he just STAYED RETIRED.
-
This is incredible
I know what it is and I’m still soooooo pissed
10/10 or also -100/10 😂
-
George Carlin, Robin Williams, Eddie Izzard, Billy Connelly
-
I know it's ragebait but I am still mad.
-
jimmy fallon is this generations mark twain
-
Doing what I can to get this on the discover tab
-
lmfao
-
Brendel, if we were in the same room right now I would kick you so hard in the nuts. As hard as I could.
-
-
only one of these legends "broke" both the cast and the audience when he laughed during the funny sketches on SNL, I think the choice is clear
-
Oh man, haven't seen you bait post in forever
-
NO DANE COOK???? ARE YOU FUCKING CRAZY?
-
You're a monster.
-
-
If you want people to yell at you just say so.
-
-
-
🎶 one of these things is not like the other 🎵
-
You diabolical monster
-
this reminds me of that one comedy special with jerry seinfeld, louis ck, ricky gervais, and chris rock lol
-
Jimmy Fallon, whose famous line “Day One. Jumping in” will forever reverberate through the hallowed halls of bluesky comedy
Only overshadowed by his second line, “Hey”
-
Legendary shitpost.
-
Top tier trolling here.
-
Bro I’m gonna fight you
-
I dunno, when you really think about it, does George Carlin really deserve to stand next to Jimmy Fallon? Feels like he's just a space filler for a spot that should go to Carlos Mencia or Dane Cook.
-
Who could forget this Naked Gun legend
-
He’s such a toad & no matter how reactive he is against Trump today, we know his character is as flimsy as wet toast & he could flipflop at any moment and Probly should
-
Jimmy Fallon doesn’t deserve to be mentioned in the same Universe as Pryor or Carlin. He’s a mugger, a phony 4th wall breaker. He’s not even a Good comedian.
-
you are a chaos machine
-
Sounds about white
-
-
It's a tough call but I can agree Andrew Dice Clay isn't in the top 4, a solid #5 though.
-
As a Brit I have to say No No No and No, but it is all personal taste.
-
😆
-
no respect, I tell ya
-
posting for the Greater Good
-
Not Fallon…
The other three did not bend a knee like Fallon.
-
The ole “wrapped finger” gag. One of Fallon’s most hilarious and satirical take downs of anal play culture.
-
Jimmy is not funny, he is silly. Big difference.
-
😂
-
Bill Maher is jelly.
-
Lmao
-
i only see one goat
-
Brendel once again with the hard truths
-
-
-
@toddbarry.bsky.social where?
-
Everyone's mad at you for this, but they forget about this:
-
what other comedian had the balls to laugh the entire time during the memorable SNL sketch about a leather store
-
"One of these things is not like the others! One of these things just doesn't belong!"
-
Carlin.
-
Oh, you’re gonna get some nibbles
-
I understand that this is a joke but I was still enraged by the idea of it
-
Fallon is an absolute piece of shit tho
-
…
-
da fuq is fallon on there for 😭
but also i'd go with Pryor. adore Carlin and got to see him live once, but feel like for impact, it's Pryor.
-
This isn't a fresh observation or anything but people who don't get it always have at least four emoji in their display name.
-
-
Really? Him?
-
-
Only one of them was so funny that he himself could not stop laughing at what he was saying and that has to count for something
-
-
You rat bastard
-
At least show the GOAT with his ape
-
Bait should not taste this good
-
I'd add Bill Hicks there
-
Nah. I ain’t touching this bait.
-
I promise you I was scrolling past on my phone not totally paying attention and then said out loud “wait, is that fucking Jimmy Fallon?”
-
Fuck Fallon.
-
Excuse me???
-
One of these things is not like the others
-
I'll give you a hint, his initials are JF. that's right. it's me, JOseph Fink
-
-
One of these is not like the other.
-
This is the equivalent of pouring a barrel of chum into the water
-
You're about to have a lot of angry Denis Leary fans in your comments.
-
Your desire to die is stronger than your desire to live, it seems.
-
-
I was biting in earnest about some others to consider (Kaufman, Chaplin, Keaton, Sellers) and only then i saw you put ff’n Fallon there.
-
Only the best comedians squeal laugh at their own jokes
-
Taps the sign
-
That Jiminy Kimble sure is a laugh man
-
Disgusting bait. Didn't include Jeff Dunham
-
Where's Jim Breuer?!?
-
-
THAT SHIT ISN'T FUNNY, MOTHERFUCKER!
-
-
The ghost of Lenny Bruce would like to have a word with you.
-
You’re missing some legends.
-
Carlin but Richard Pryor could be my pick on a different day.
-
Jimmy Fallon over TJ Miller? AYFC?!
-
-
I see you are on your shit again
-
I don’t know man, Lenny Bruce’s influence was titanic. You gotta think about swapping him in for Murphy
-
If you think we can agree you have your head up your ass.
Fallon and Murphy aren't the peers of the others or Marx or Keaton
-
This is carrot top erasure.
-
Including Fallon was pretty funny, but Pauly Shore woulda been hilarious.
RIMSHOT
-
-
delet this
-
Brendel no
-
You just threw the whole fishing pole into the pond lmao....
-
I can’t tell if only 1 or 2 of these is a fake answer.
-
Jimmy Fallon lol have you only ever seen these four comedians? Not sure he even technically qualifies as a comedian
-
-
One of these things is not like the other. One of these things doesn’t belong.
-
-
You gotta admit tho, getting on SNL by doing impressions of people who are actually funny is a smart trick
-
-
Swap out Carlin for Dane Cook and Kevin Hart in Richard Pryor. Eddie Murphy can stay, but only Coming 2 America, Eddie.
-
Where’s carrot top
-
Robin Williams needs to pop down from Heaven to kick Jimmy Fallon out of his seat.
-
-
-
You just wanna start sh*t, right? 🤣🤣🤣
This needs all manner of qualifiers.
Red Foxx is missing. That’s only your first error. Moms Mabley is your second. Bernie Mac, Sam Kinison, Robin Harris all missing. Fallon on par with Pryor? Murphy on par with Carlin or Pryor?🥴
-
-
No one has done it better
-
Rodmy Damgerfield
-
Uh, looks like someone forgot Jay Leno.
-
think you forgot a couple
-
Fuckin’ jump scare me like that. Not cool.
-
You chose chaos today
-
First time I ever got wasted was 4/10/92.
I was visiting a friend at college and someone got the news that Sam Kinison had died. We had a giant listening party in the dorm lounge and the booze flowed like angry screams.
-
Rodney
-
Is top right Rip Taylor?
-
Dude.
-
-
Definitely not Jimmy Fallon for me. Of these 4, I’d go with George Carlin.
-
Lolllll
-
@pfrazee.com do something! Can’t you ban him?
-
oh fuck off brendel lmao
-
Why’d you put Eddie Murphy on there twice? Anyways I’d put Jay Leno in the mix too - just good wholesome JOKES without all the politics! 😡
-
I'd pick Richard Pryor barely over George Carlin. Both were masters at their craft.
-
BRRREEEENNNDDDEEELLLLLL!!!!!!!!!!! shakes fist
-
Out of those four there’s a real consensus as to who the best one is, and I don’t even have to mention it. We all know it
-
Are you feeling okay?
-
only one of these guys ever slow jammed the news.
the choice is clear.
-
Someone woke up and chose a bit of the ol' ultra-violence.
-
Whoever has the most famous sketch wins
-
🤔
-
-
uhh that’s eddie murphy’s stand-in
-
fallon, for how he healed the nation through his home shows during the pandemic, just thinking about those pop song covers done on toy instruments is literally healing my long covid
-
-
i hadn’t seen a recent picture of fallon in years, his head is completely normal still and in no way is he turning into a baldwin
-
I think about this clip every day youtu.be/Byi6yFJMoVQ?...
-
-
The loofah bit changed the game
-
Where’s George Gobel?
-
Come now. You laughed with these guys.
-
I think that picture is after he tore his finger off because he's a fall-down drunk. And that's not even the funniest drug-induced mishap out of those four comics!
-
Weirdly enough I get more bad vibes from Carlin, who I came to despise, than Fallon who I don't think about at all.
-
Does seem to have a 20th century bias. What, no Richard Tarlton?
-
Nope. We do not agree. I find Jimmy Fallon too be just smug.
The rest I would put on the Mount Rushmore of comedy, for sure.
-
From the POV of breaking through social conventions and norms, you have to place JF at the top.
-
truly the cruelty of this list is leaving one of most subtle and overlooked comedians Carrottop
-
don't be too shy to include yourself in the pantheon, esp. after this post
-
most people are not smart enough to understand Jimmy Fallon
-
This post proves you should be considered one of the top comedians of all time
-
This is some of your best work
-
Is this like the Sesame Street "one of these is not like the others" game?
-
One of these things is not like the other. One of these things just doesn't belong.
-
